Please crit harshly. :D

Showcase your artistic works here for all to admire and critique. All forms of art are welcome.
Forum rules
The purpose of this forum is to allow individuals to post their artwork for admiration and critique; it is NOT for promoting your comic (see Self-Promotion). It is strictly forbidden to create a topic with the sole purpose of linking to your comic.

Please crit harshly. :D

Postby ArsArc » May 3rd, 2012, 8:30 pm

Hello,

If you've got some free time, I'd really appreciate some thoughts on my script for a story I call "Chambermaid Abbadon"

Chambermaid Abbadon is a kind of personal project that I've been working on and reshaping for quite awhile. What you see here is just rewrite of the many previous versions I've done. It is the vehicle from which I navigate and explore the possibilities of manga writing and story telling.

I'm always looking for artists to work with and new projects to start, so if you need a writer and you like my writing feel free to give me a PM.

Setting:

Spoiler! :
A once technologically advanced planet that had suffered an apocalyptic event thousands of years ago. After the decline of civilization humanity went through a period where humans reverted back to being primitive savages. Thousands of years later the population is on the cusp of recovering and pre-industrial technology that had been reinvented is wide spread.

Pieces of lost technology and ruin is still scattered throughout the world. They are avoided for superstitious reasons and anyone who wants to investigate them are considered witches, warlocks, heathens etc.

For thousands of years the planet and its surrounding space had been (and is still) completely isolated from an intergalactic human civilization by interstellar storms. These storms draw closer bit by bit.

The storms surrounding the planet are dimensional tears in the universe that bleeds madness into the galaxy. The closer one gets the more they feel the effects of it. It brings out and enhances the most self destructive qualities of men and women. They have been slowly approaching the planet like the fingers of a man closing around and grasping a ball.

It is unknown what might happen once the storms reach the planets atmosphere. The citizens thus far in the beginning of the story are not even aware the storms exist. They only have a vague idea that the planet was a virtual utopia at one point.



Chapter One

Code: Select all
          EXT. SPACE ABOVE EARTH-LIKE PLANET

          A tube shaped space colony floats just above the atmosphere.
          It looks to be in a state of disrepair. There are no lights
          coming from inside. A ring of debris orbits around it.

          Suddenly, there is a large explosion off the port of the
          giant construct; spraying debris into cold space.

          The hull of the massive construct begins to light up as it
          enters the atmosphere.

                                                        BLACK BOX

          EXT. A DESERT VALLEY AFTER RAIN FALL - FOGGY MORNING

          It is early morning and a thick fog permeates over a flat
          and cracked desert ground that seems to go on forever.

          A dark figure (Helvetica) can be seen emerging from the fog.
          The sound of her taking breath is rhythmic.

          Helvetica's mouth hangs slightly open as she controls her
          breathing.

                              HELVETICA
                         (heavy breathing)
                   

          We watch from the side, putting into perspective the vast
          space in which she is jogging. She looks small in
          comparison.

                              HELVETICA
                         (controlled breathing, small)
                   

          Helvetica stops in her tracks, a tiny flower with moisture
          dripping off its pedals sits by her feet.

          She exhales and slows her breathing. A bead of sweat wells
          up on her chin.

          Helvetica walks off towards a tall ivory tower just ahead.
          The flower and its roots have been dug out from the ground.

          TITLE: Chambermaid Abbadon

          INT. IVORY TOWER HALL - FOGGY MORNING

          We follow Helvetica as she walks through a dark and long
          white walled hallway. The walls are cracked and caked with
          dust, the bulbs have been exploded, the ground is made of
          dark marble.

          There are old portraits lining the wall. All of them appear to be
          photographs with a seperate name on each of them. They are
          all portraits of children.

          A close up of a portrait that is different. Rather than a
          photograph; it's actually a crude drawing of a young smiling
          girl.

          Looking closer still, we see a name, it writes "Helvetica".

          INT. IVORY TOWER STAIR - FOGGY MORNING

          We look down on her as she emerges into a large chamber with
          an industrial spiral staircase leading up. Contrasted on the
          dark marbelled ground floor is a symbol that has long lost
          its meaning.

          She grabs the railings as she makes her ascent.

          Helvetica makes her way up the tower, her figure small in
          the cavernous tower. Along the staircase are many doors
          leading to many different rooms.

          INT. IVORY TOWER UPPER DECK - EARLY MORNING, STILL DARK

          Finally she reaches the top; an airy opening. A light breeze
          blows and sways her hair.

          She stands alone on the upper deck. It has an inverted
          conical ceiling with pillars to support the weight of the
          roof. There are no walls blocking out the elements on this
          level. She looks small in this large wall less chamber. The
          sky around them is still dark, stars can be seen. It is
          almost as if they are in a space ship.

          The closer you are to the middle the lower the ground is.

          There is vegetation wrapping bench tables, chairs, and what
          could pass as contemporary art constructions, all
          constructed by the same stone used to construct the
          building. It looks like an out door play ground over run
          with vines and foliage.

          We look from above as she walks forward, we can tell the
          ground up here is all soil.

          She unstraps her sheathed sword and puts it down, leaning it
          against the side of the base of a large pillar.

          Helvetica bends down to plant the flower, she gets on her
          knee.

          As she begin digging with her hands a voice speaks out. Her
          hands pause.

                              PALATINO
                    You're late.

          Helvetica turns her face to see a young boy, 5 years her
          junior, sitting on the flat base of a large marble pillar.

                              PALATINO
                         (Concern)
                    What were you doing? Were you
                    thinking of abandoning me?

                              HELVETICA
                         (Amusement)
                    I would think of doing no such
                    thing.

          Palatino turns his head away stubbornly raising his chin and
          shutting his eyes. The sun starting rise.

                              PALATINO
                         (Dejected)
                    ...It's not like I am worried about
                    you, but you should stop leaving
                    the tower. There's perfectly enough
                    space to stretch your legs here.

          Helvetica stands and smiles warmly, the sun coming up from
          behind her.

                              HELVETICA
                         (mild joy)
                    You worry too much, Palatino.

          Palatino objects, a look of indignation and embarrassment on
          his face

                              PALATINO
                         (embarassed)
                    I just said I wasn't!

                              HELVETICA
                         (laughing, amused)
                    No need to be so —

          Suddenly, they are alerted by a loud voice shouting from
          below, they turn to face the direction of the voice.

                              CHIEF GUARD
                    Oi! Witch!! Witch!! Come down here!

                              PALATINO
                         (annoyed)
                    He's back again? Why can't he just
                    leave you alone?

                              HELVETICA
                    Something tells me he's come for a
                    different reason this time.

          Helvetica heads for the stairs, bending down to retrieve her
          sword.

                              HELVETICA
                    Stay here.

          Palatino walks up after her.

                              PALATINO
                    Don't you ever get tired of going
                    up and down those stairs?

          Helvetica is already on her way down, she waves her hand up

                              HELVETICA
                    You get use to it. Try not to make
                    too much noise, okay?

          Helvetica disappears down the stairs,

          Palatino sighs. He looks to his side and sees a steaming
          smithing furnace. He walks over to it and picks up a hammer
          and tong, preparing to continue his work.

          Suddenly a beam of sun light strikes his eyes, he looks
          towards it. His eyes widen, shocked at what he's seeing.

          The hammer drops to the ground with a dull thud.

          EXT. IVORY TOWER ENTRANCE - SUNNY MORNING

          A bunch of armored guards carrying primative muskets and
          halberds stand by the door. A primitive troop carrier with a
          loud engine and smoking exhaust idles near them

          The Chief guard, a skinny man of medium height with a rather
          well groomed mustache and comb over stands attentively,
          waiting. The troops are jittery and nervous.

          The chief notices a shadow approaching from within the hall
          of the building.

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (Yelling orders)
                    Attention!!

          The guards all run forward and stand shoulder to shoulder
          behind the Chief. They aim their muskets forward. The guards
          aim nervously, some of them are shaking.

                              HELVETICA
                         (in the shadow of the
                         interior)
                    What's the meaning of this?

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (Nervous, Stern)
                    By the order of the prime magistar
                    I hereby arrest the7th generation
                    offspring of the banished family!
                    Neue Hass Gro-

          Helvetica appears almost out of thin air, kicking up a
          circle of dust around her as she points the tip of her blade
          against the chief guards throat.

                              HELVETICA
                         (Stern)
                    You don't want to finish that. Now
                    get on with it. What is the meaning
                    of this?

          The troops all tense up, aiming fearfully at Helvetica.

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (Fearful, cautioning)
                    Wait.

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (Gulps, fearful)
                    We've come to retrieve you for
                    crimes against humanity.

                              HELVETICA
                         (Wonder)
                    Crimes? What crimes?

          Suddenly Helvetica notices cars, civilian vehicles that look
          like victorian era cars speeding by. They all seem to be
          lugging a lot of packaging and are all fleeing from
          the same place.

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (Fear, Spite, pointing to
                         whats beside the tower in the
                         distance)
                    See for yourself.

          Helvetica lowers her weapon, she is
          looking off into the distance.

          She see's the giant space colony penetrating a thick wall of
          clouds over a city castle built into the side of a small
          mountain. It is suspended above the city. Thousands of people
          are escaping the city on vehicles and on foot.

          Helvetica narrows and shields her eyes to get a better look.

                              HELVETICA
                         (turning her head back to
                         look)
                    What is it?

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (folding his arms, grim)
                    That's what we're here to find out.
                    The magistar is convinced that you
                    had something to do with it... you
                    must come with us.

                              HELVETICA
                         (Stern)
                    Do you really think I am
                    responsible for the appearance of
                    that thing?

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (Sighing)
                    ...No. I don't. But it doesn't
                    matter what I think now, does it?

                              HELVETICA
                         (sheathing sword)
                    Of course it does.

          Helvetica looks near the door way briefly, as if
          contemplating something.

                              HELVETICA
                         (looking at the chief)
                    Where will you be taking me?

          The chief guard starts walking to his vehicle, his guards
          follow

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (back facing us)
                    We'll be going straight to the
                    magistars mansion. Things
                    are hectic and the courts are
                    filled with minor cases.

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (turning his head, grinning
                         nervously)
                    I never took you to be a cautious
                    girl, what's the matter? Things get
                    difficult you could simply swing
                    that sword of yours around and
                    disappear.

          Helvetica glances back to the doorway one more time.

                              HELVETICA
                    Things are different now.

                              CHIEF GUARD
                         (concerned, wonder)
                    Course. Of course they are. Now
                    come. The magistar awaits.

          The driver puts the truck in gear and steps on the throttle.
          The transport truck drives towards the city, against the
          tide of escaping citizens.

          INT. IVORY TOWER HALL - DARK

          Palatino stands in the dark threshold of the entrance to the
          ivory tower, looking down in silent contemplation.

          He balls his hand into a tightly wound fist.



Chapter Two

Code: Select all
EXT. CLOVELOCK CITY

          The dark streets are strangely empty of people.

                              ????
                    Fix reason firmly in her seat

          Above, the ancient space colony floats, casting an omnious
          shadow over the entire city.

                              ????
                    Call to her tribunal every fact,
                    every opinion.

          The streets are littered with belongings and abandoned
          vehicles. Horses wander around, ownerless.

                              ????
                    Quesion with boldness even the
                    existence of god.

          A lone transport navigates through the streets.

                              ????
                    Because, if there be one..  (Thomas J.)

          EXT. MAGISTARS MANSION

          It arrives at a massive mansion with fortress like walls
          containing a vast field of bright grass. An elevated road
          leads directly to the mansion.

                              ????
                    He must more approve of the homage
                    of reason.

          Helvetica looks out the window and sees guards and random
          people littering the grass field, all standing and unmoving.
          They stare up mindlessly, like their minds have been broken.

                              ????
                    Than that of blind folded fear.

          TITLE: Chambermaid Abbadon

          INT. MAGISTARS MANSION PRIVATE CHAMBER

          The magistar sits on a pool table, his eyes glowing
          melancholy. He is quite young, no more than 3-4 years older
          than Helvetica.

                              MAGISTAR
                    Do you know why I have summoned you
                    here, Helvetica?

          Helvetica stands at the far corner of the room near the
          entrance, she is alone but still armed.

                              HELVETICA
                    Your chief informed me.

          A shelf nearby catches Helvetica's attention, they are lined
          with pictures of the same little girl. They are all drawn.
          The Magistar walks closer to Helvetica

                              MAGISTAR
                         (laughing oddly dramatically,
                         sarcastically)
                    No, no ,no. That is not why I
                    brought you here.

          He waves a finger.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (mild joy)
                    That was an excuse.

          The magistar is in front of Helvetica now, he watches
          Helvetica curiously as she looks at the pictures.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (leaning on the shelf)
                    Father was quite fond of you, you
                    know? He offered you a place here
                    but no. You'd rather live in that
                    wretched tower with your wretched
                    mother.

                              HELVETICA
                         (Contemplation)
                    ...

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Desperation in his eyes)
                    Why?

          The magistar grabs her chin and looks her in the eye

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Mild Anger)
                    You could have ended it. This
                    lineage of witches and warlocks. He
                    would have accepted both you and
                    your mother. You two could have
                    lived here in comfort. In peace.

                              HELVETICA
                         (Slapping his hand away)
                    I was more more at peace out there
                    than I ever was in this city.

          The magistar looks down at the drawings. In one picture the
          little girl is in town waving a pipe and chasing people.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (mock amusement)
                    Is that why you kept coming back to
                    terrorize the city? Because of all
                    that peace?

                              HELVETICA
                         (mild joy)
                    No. Because of boredom.

          The magistar looks at Helvetica's smile with a hint of
          suprise and a deep sense of longing. Suddenly he is
          disappointed.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Concern)
                    I... I've called you here because
                    I've been hearing things. Things
                    about a boy...

          Helvetica is holding up a picture and looking at it,
          uninterested.

                              HELVETICA
                         (Indifferent)
                    His name is Palatino. And you did
                    not call me here, you had me
                    arrested.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Disgust)
                    Yes... He's young, isn't he?

                              HELVETICA
                         (Mild joy)
                    So?

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Moderate anger)
                    Too young! He can't possibly father
                    you a child!

                              HELVETICA
                         (Sterness, slightly concerned)
                    Did I say I wanted one...? I think
                    you're getting the wrong idea here.

          The magistar grabs Helvetica by the shoulder, a desperate
          look in his eyes.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Pleading, desperate)
                    I can do it. Let me be the
                    father... I can do it before—

                              HELVETICA
                         (Stern, spooked)
                    Have you gone mad? Let me go.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Desperate, fearful, smiling)
                    before the end, before it happens!
                    that whelp doesn't deserve you. Not
                    like I do, he won't be able to—

                              HELVETICA
                         (Under breath, angry)
                    Let. Me. Go.

          On go Helvetica punches the Magistar across the face.

          He drops on one knee as Helvetica backs away, hand on the
          handle of her sword.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (On one knee, holding his
                         bruised face)
                    Witch!! Dreadful witch!!

          The door bursts open and guards with muskets drawn flood in.
          The Magistar begins closing in on Helvetica, backing her
          near the window.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Slouching, dragging feet,
                         sadness)
                    All these years... I've waited...
                    waited for the day when I can take
                    you into my arms...

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Covering face, eyes wide)
                    And you take in this... this
                    whelp?! ...This child?! Who do you
                    think it was that made your life so
                    comfortable in that wretched
                    tower?!

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Shouting, betrayed, insane)
                    It was me! me!! And now you repay
                    me with this... treachery?! Do you
                    how that makes me feel?! Do you?!

          A tick tick sound comes from the window.

          The sound of water hitting it. Helvetica tilts her head to
          get a better look outside. The rain is thick and dark. The
          color of blood.

          The room becomes darker, blood oozing on the window.

          The guards all have slasher smiles with spit leaking down
          their mouths. Their clothes are stained with blood. Their
          eyes wide open.

                              MAGISTAR
                    Enough. I've waited enough.

                              MAGISTAR
                         (Shadowed except for the
                         whites of his eyes)
                    Take your clothes off. Sis.

          EXT. DESERT VALLEY - AFTERNOON, CLOUDY

          An victorian vehicle with FRUTIGER and TIMES ROMAN[driver]
          is heading towards the city, They are dressed in the uniform
          of a certain organization.

          There are only a few vehicles leaving the city now.

          Most of the vehicles leaving now are stained red with blood.

          INT. VICTORIAN VEHICLE - AFTERNOON, CLOUDY.

          Frutiger sits up and sticks his head out the window to look
          at some people they had just passed.

                              FRUTIGER
                         (wonder, suprise)
                    Woah! Did you see that? Those folks
                    were covered in blood!

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Stern, wearing shades)
                    Keep your head down! You don't know
                    when we might encounter the enemy.

                              FRUTIGER
                         (Disdain)
                    Enemy? I don't know about you, but
                    I doubt there's anything here we
                    can consider "enemies"...

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Anger, disgust)
                    Fool! Do you not see how they flee?
                    The citizens are in a state of
                    panic, in fear. Do you know what
                    fear breeds in such high population
                    densities?

                              FRUTIGER
                         (Mild Joy)
                    Heroes?

                              TIME ROMAN
                         (Outrage, turning to face
                         Frutiger)
                    No you blithering idiot.

          Frutiger leans his elbow on the railing as he listens to
          Times Roman rant.

                              TIMES ROMAN
                    It breeds religion. The most foul
                    kind of courage that works hand in
                    hand with ignorance. It spreads
                    like a bloody cancer. The kind
                    that—

          Frutiger opens his eyes wide as the vehicle rapidly
          approaches the figure of a young boy with his hands spread.

          He takes control of the steering wheel to steer the car
          away.

                              FRUTIGER
                         (Grabbing steering wheel,
                         shock, anger)
                    Woah! watch out!

          The car barely misses Palatino who was standing in its path
          with his hands spead. He is holding his forging hammer.

          The car drifts into a dusty stop. Times Roman leans out and
          yells at him.

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Enraged)
                    What's wrong with you child?! You
                    looking to get yourself killed?!

          Palatino walks up to the window, his body shaking with
          anxiety. He isn't use to dealing with strangers.

                              PALATINO
                         (Nervous, concerned,
                         determined)
                    Y-you're heading into the city
                    right?

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Suprised, concerned)
                    Yeah, why?

                              PALATINO
                         (Determined)
                    Take me with you!

          Times and Frutiger pause to look at each other, not knowing
          how to react. Times smirks wickedly under her breath.

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Under breath)
                    Heh.

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Mocking)
                    You some kinda hero, kid?

          Palatino pauses, unsure of how to answer.

                              PALATINO
                         (Looking away, shy)
                    I... I... I just need to make sure
                    someone is alright...

          Times roman leans on the door and looks and Palatino with a
          teasing smile

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (teasing)
                    hmmm... really?

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Turning to frutiger, curious)
                    What say you, Frutiger? Shall we
                    take him a long?

                              FRUTIGER
                         (Leaning back, annoyed)
                    Stop teasing the kid and let him
                    in. Better that he sticks with us
                    than wander out here alone.

                              TIMES ROMAN
                         (Faint hope)
                    Well, I don't know about that.
Last edited by ArsArc on May 4th, 2012, 10:34 pm, edited 4 times in total.
ArsArc
 
Posts: 2
Joined: March 17th, 2012, 3:04 pm

Re: Please crit harshly. :D

Postby HABE » May 4th, 2012, 1:16 pm

My very harsh, completely subjective first impressions. If I were a submissions editor, this is what I would tell you:

The title: Unless this story is a comedy about a maid in Hell, which I would LOVE to see, this title seems like a mistake. It gives me the impression you've been overly influenced by too much bad anime.

The setting: It's been a while since I've seen a Gamma World type of story, so this seemed like it could be fun. I would have preferred to see the tech level described as 19th-Century or Industrial-Revolution era rather than Victorian. You yourself seem to recognize the overdone trendiness of this setting in genre mixing, and it would have saved you from the awkwardness of including that disclaimer about it not being steam punk. It's always better to say what something is rather than what it isn't.

The "cosmic storms" and intergalactic civilizations concepts suddenly introduced next seem to clash with the setting you just described and have the potential for all kinds of technical problems. I'll give it a wary benefit of the doubt, but the story seems more unfocused now and suggests everything will be less serious in the style of "it doesn't have to make sense" manga sort of way.

Edit: Leading with a story summary explaining how all these things are related might have made the setting description feel less of a hodgepodge. Right now, it's like you start promising one thing then deliver another.

Characters: The basic-font-based character names and animal motifs made me cringe and lose hope that this will be any good. The long, abstract, astrology-style descriptions ensured I would not read them, just as most people don't read other people's horoscopes. Airy general quality descriptions don't mean anything by themselves and could describe anything or anyone in any story. There's nothing specific here that might bring the character to life for me or make me want to know more. (The animal motifs might be good for hashing out designs with an artist, but in the description they make me think they were inspired by a gimmicky How to Write article you found on some lame writing blog.)

Chapter 1: Combined with the above impressions, that grammar error in the third line of the first paragraph (after I already forgave the missing hyphen in "Earth-Like") made me think the rest was probably not polished enough to be worth reading any further. That's where I stopped.

Sorry, but you did say harsh :)
User avatar
HABE
 
Posts: 147
Joined: January 14th, 2007, 1:16 pm

Re: Please crit harshly. :D

Postby ArsArc » May 4th, 2012, 9:58 pm

Thanks for the crit!

Admittedly you've made me feel quite embarrassed and ashamed of myself but this is the kind of feed back I'm looking for. :lol:

Things I will do:

- Fix grammatical issues
- Change "victorian" to "pre industrial revolution"
- Remove character sheets and keep those to myself and the artist(s)
- Write a story summary

Things I may eventually do:

- Change character names
- Change title

Let me know if I'm missing anything~
ArsArc
 
Posts: 2
Joined: March 17th, 2012, 3:04 pm


Return to Creative Showcase

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests